Tuesday, February 14, 2012

Why We Need Emphatic Science


From the very beginning of the scientific tradition in the sixteenth century, not everyone agreed with the notion that the secrets of nature had to be pried loose from a reluctant source. A notable example is the German polymath Johann Wolfgang von Goethe (1749-1832). Goethe, the author of Faust and many other diverse works, was a major force; his work influenced philosophers such as Hegel, Schopenhauer, Nietzsche, Cassirer, Jung and Wittgenstein. He was opposed to the scientific method of the day, which emphasized objectivity, neutrality and remoteness. He believed the understanding of nature came through participation. To understand a plant, e.g., one must enter into the life of the plant. He called his scientific approach “a delicate empiricism which in a most inward way makes itself identical with the object and thereby becomes the actual theory.”
It’s easy to disregard Goethe as a crank who couldn’t get with the scientific program, but he is not so easily dismissed. Echoes of Goethe’s approach keep cropping up. An example is Nobel geneticist Barbara McClintock, who worked with genes and corn plants. She once said that her success was due to the fact that she had “a feeling for the organism.” That’s putting it mildly. McClintock would psychologically enter into a problem so deeply that she became the problem. She would cease to exist as a person; on emerging from contemplating the issue, she literally could not remember her name. Goethe would have understood.
As Jeremy Rifkin shows, Goethe’s theme of participatory science was taken up 130 years later by Heinz Kohut (1913-1981), the eminent Austrian-born American psychoanalyst. Kohut believed that conventional scientific methodology was “experience-distant,” removed from actual observation. He proposed an “experience-near” approach as an alternative, in which data could be acquired directly from empathy and introspection. Empathy was crucial, he maintained, to prevent scientific pursuits from “becoming increasingly isolated from human life.” Eliminating empathy from science had resulted in a cold, disinterested and rational approach that fostered the aims of brutal totalitarian regimes and had led to “some of the most inhuman goals the world has ever known.” Summing up, Kohut said that the new ideal in science “can be condensed into a single evocative phrase: we must strive not only for scientific empathy but also for an empathic science.”
American psychologist Abraham Maslow (1908-1970) agreed with Kohut. He was scornful of the idea of a neutral observer who is uninvolved and removed from her object of study. He specified that that the goal of an empathic approach was not to destroy conventional science, but to enlarge it.
Henry David Thoreau, an American original who loved knowledge, knew as much. “If you would learn the secrets of nature,” he insisted, “you must practice more humanity than others.”
I recall a moment of colossal confusion as a university student that might have been tempered had I known about Kohut’s views. I had fallen in love with science in high school but had not yet decided on a specific career choice. One evening I attended a campus lecture by a visiting scientist eminent in his field. Someone in the audience asked whether scientists were justified in researching lethal microbes and chemical nerve agents whose sole purpose was to kill human beings. Without a nanosecond’s pause he responded enthusiastically, “Of course they should be free to research these things. You cannot rein in the human mind. It should be free to explore anything. Scientists have no responsibility for how these things are used. Politicians do that.” His imperious attitude implied that only an imbecile would ask such a question in the first place. I was gobsmacked. At the time I thought this was the most selfish, arrogant and utterly stupid comment I had ever heard. I wasn’t alone. The entire audience was hushed in disbelief. I went away bewildered and perplexed. This was science? Now I know why Goethe, Kohut and Maslow are important cairns along the path of science. They are correctives to the notion that science should ideally be done by brains on sticks — humans who honor only the intellect and are devoid of empathy, who divorce themselves totally from ethical and moral issues.
Rifkin believes that Kohut’s “experience-near” approach and Maslow’s notion of “caring subjectivity” in science have been influential in the more than half century since they were proposed. He observes, “A new generation of researchers, like Jane Goodall in primatology, have used the ‘experience-near,’ empathic approach to scientific investigation, to elicit new discoveries and insights about the nature of nature that would have been impossible to imagine using the traditional disinterested, value-neutral, scientific method.”
Jane Goodall is a telling example. When her mentor, anthropologist Louis Leakey, sent her in 1960 to study chimpanzees in Gombe National Park in Tanzania, she had no training as a scientist. Goodall explains, “He wanted someone whose mind was uncluttered by scientific theory because back then ethology was trying to make itself into a hard science and was very reductionistic — very reductionistic.” Her project became one of the longest continuous field studies of any animal. She produced startling discoveries of chimpanzee behavior, such as meat-eating and the fashioning and use of tools. Like McClintock, Goodall intuitively understood the wisdom of an empathic approach to field research. She gave names to her subjects and became emotionally engaged with them, which horrified more than a few ethologists and evoked stern criticism. Goodall remains unapologetic. In a recent interview she stated, “There is absolutely no problem in having empathy and being objective. Empathy helps us gain an understanding at a different level that you can then test in a rigorous scientific way.”
References
  • Rifkin J. The Empathic Civilization. New York, NY: Tarcher/Penguin; 2009: 307-309.
  • Goethe JWV. Maximen und Reflexionen. Köln, Germany: Anaconda Verlag GmbH; 2008: 435.
  • Keller EF. A Feeling for the Organism. New York, NY: Times Books; 1984:101.
  • Kohut H. The psychoanalyst in the community of scholars. In: Ornstein PH (ed.). The Search for the Self: Selected Writings of Heinz Kohut: 1950-1978. Vol. 1. New York, NY: International Universities Press; 1978: 82.
  • Kohut H. The psychoanalyst in the community of scholars. In: Ornstein PH (ed.). The Search for the Self: Selected Writings of Heinz Kohut: 1950-1978. Vol. 2. New York, NY: International Universities Press; 1978: 174.
  • Kohut H. The psychoanalyst in the community of scholars. In: Ornstein PH (ed.). The Search for the Self: Selected Writings of Heinz Kohut: 1950-1978. Vol. 1. New York, NY: International Universities Press; 1978: 707.
  • Rifkin J. The Empathic Civilization. New York, NY: Tarcher/Penguin; 2009: 609.
  • Maslow AH. The Psychology of Science: A Renaissance. South Bend, IN: Gateway Editions, Ltd. 1966: 50.
  • Thoreau HD. Quoted in: Eiseley L. The Man Who Saw Through Time. New York, NY: Scribner’s; 1961: 113.
  • Rifkin J. The Empathic Civilization. New York, NY: Tarcher/Penguin; 2009: 611.
  • Goodall J. Leakey’s angel, 50 years on. Interview of Jane Goodall by Charlotte Uhlenbroek. New Scientist. February 20, 2010; 205 (2748): 28-29.

Monday, February 13, 2012

How To Be Lucky !



It is easy and normal to have moments where you feel depressed or down on yourself. If you have these moments often, or are having a day where you feel very unlucky, here is how to help yourself realise that you actually are lucky, and should feel happy. Being lucky can happen in many different forms!
  1. Change your perspective of what luck means. Luck is often considered to be something “out there”, out of our personal control. We expect something (or someone) lucky to descend on us and improve life for us. Waiting around for luck instead of creating it is a fool’s game that can lead you to constant negative thinking, including always seeing other people’s good fortune as the result of “luck” rather than choices.
  2. Use your willpower, not your imagination. For some of us, it’s easier to fall into fantasy thinking instead of focused and directed thinking about the purpose of our life.
  3. Visualize success. Develop your own powerful inner feeling that consists of telling yourself: “This is really going to work and I must work hard at it.”
  4. Think about things you normally take for granted, such as having hot water or the Internet. Challenge yourself go without it. If you find it is too important to do without, consider how lucky you are to have access to it.
  5. Listen to, watch or read the news every once in awhile. You’re sure to hear about plenty of bad things happening to people around the world. Consider how lucky you are not be involved.
  6. Remember positive things that have happened to you in the past. Think about the circumstances that created those events and whether they can be recreated. If not, consider how lucky you are that everything co-ordinated to make that event occur.
  7. Do something different. Dye your hair, go to the beach, be spontaneous! Make a list of the stupidest things you can think of and then just do them! Make sure you’re with a friend though ‘cos other wise you will just look weird.
  8. Be nice to people. Your mom, dad, friends, teacher, cleaner or whatever. Just be nice towards them. If you are nice to them then they will be nice back. Seriously, don’t waste time being angry at everybody, because the truth is, you are probably mad at yourself.
  9. Be confident. Even if you are the shyest person ever. Even if you go red when people talk to you, get sweaty hands or food stuck between your teeth ALL the time. If you don’t know how to actually be confident then just pretend you are confident. Act like you don’t have a care in the world and it will rub off on other people. Just remember that everybody is special and unique. Even if your special gift is knowing all about Neighbours or having an ‘inner calm’ or even being the person who always takes jokes too far, there is always something that make you special to people.

Spiritual Living In Educations

FROM A DROP 
TO AN OCEAN




The pioneer had returned home after nearly
five decades. He looked across a room full of
his African brothers and sisters. His deep and
passionate voice echoed through the room and
across the crowd.
He was telling them a story about one of the
dearest friends he had ever had. He was telling
them about the great Enoch Olinga, one of the
first African Bahá’ís




“Before Mr. Olinga became a Bahá’í, he was a
drop. Through his service, as a Bahá’í, he
became an ocean. ”
“This is true. It can happen!”
“The question is how? How to go from a little
mosquito to an eagle?”
“Bahá’u’lláh can change us. We must pray to
Him, daily, and beg Him to change us. If our
prayer is sincere – and it’s combined with
action and deeds and purity of motive – bit by
bit, we will change. We can do what Mr. Olinga
did.” Let’s look at Enoch Olinga’s life. See if
you agree with the wise pioneer …
Enoch Olinga was a translator. He was very
good at it. But despite this, he had, over time
become sad and disheartened. To escape his
disillusionment, he turned to alcohol, which
only  made  him  feel  worse.  He  drank  so  much
that he eventually lost the job he was so good
at.




He didn’t know what to do. How would he
support his family? What would he tell his
parents? He felt hopeless until he heard about
the Bahá’í Faith. At the time, in 1951 there
were few Bahá’ís in Africa.
He  began  trying  to  find  an  answer  to  his
problem by going to meetings in the homes of
Bahá’í pioneers. One very special evening the
pioneers held a meeting that coincided with the
time that Shoghi Effendi visited the Holy
Shrines in Haifa to pray. Mr. Olinga attended
the meeting and left when it was over, only to
return later.
He asked lots of questions. The most important
one he left for last: “How does one become a
Bahá’í?”
He came back the next morning and brought
with him a letter asking to be accepted as a
Bahá’í. That’s how Enoch Olinga became one of
the first Bahá’ís in the country of Uganda.




When he became a Bahá’í, Mr. Olinga gave up
drinking alcohol immediately. His behavior
changed so remarkably that his wife also
became a Bahá’í. His neighbors also noticed
how he had changed. So they became Bahá’ís
too. Within a few months there were enough
Bahá’ís in Kampala, the city where Mr. Olinga
lived, to form a Local Spiritual Assembly.
He had been so successful in Kampala, that he
decided to travel to his parents’ hometown and
teach the Faith there too. During a short time
nearly 100 people, including Enoch’s own
parents, accepted the message of Bahá'u'lláh.
Within a few years the  number of Bahá’ís in
Uganda had reached over 200. Shoghi Effendi
was so happy about this that he wrote a letter
to the entire Bahá’í world praising the success
of Enoch Olinga and his friends.
His success in teaching, served as an example
to his Bahá’í friends – an example of how to
reach the heart through loving kindness and a
cheerful nature. These qualities shone forth from Enoch. Their source was Mr. Olinga’s love
for Bahá’u’lláh and His Teaching, and
obedience to His Laws.
When Shoghi Effendi wrote letters to the
African Bahá’ís encouraging them to travel
around and teach about the Faith, Mr. Olinga
and two of his Bahá’í friends responded
immediately. They decided to make a 3,000
mile trip all the way across the African
continent to carry Bahá'u'lláh’s message to the
British Cameroons.
The trip was hard. Heavy rain turned the dirt
roads on which they drove into rivers of mud.
The travelers’ car got stuck in the mud so
many times that one day it finally gave out and
died. There was nowhere to go. The nearest
city was more than 50 miles away. Enoch
Olinga, who had never  lived outside the big
city, told his friends to stay in the safety of the
car and walked away to bring help. He walked
through the wet dangerous jungle, through the
mud that covered his feet up to his ankles, past trees that housed poisonous snakes, and
bushes that hid wild  and hungry animals. He
kept on walking until he fell down and passed
out in exhaustion.
Shoghi Effendi had promised that his prayers
would accompany the travelers on the journey.
Now, passed out on the ground in exhaustion,
Enoch Olinga really needed Shoghi Effendi’s
prayers. In this moment of desperation and
need, Shoghi Effendi came to him in a dream.
He helped him to get back up on his feet. Then
he praised and encouraged him and assured
him that he will succeed.
Mr.  Olinga  woke  up  a  different  person.  He  felt
determined to continue. As he began to walk
again, his friends caught up with him. They
had been able to repair the car and had come
to rescue him.
Two months after they set out, the pioneers
reached their destination. Because there were
no Bahá’ís living there,  Mr. Olinga decided to settle down and live in the country we now
know as Cameroon. For this, Shoghi Effendi
gave him the title “Knight of Bahá'u'lláh”.
2
Several years later, Enoch Olinga made a
pilgrimage to the Holy Land to visit the
Shrines, becoming the first black African to
make the pilgrimage. On this visit he also met
his beloved Shoghi Effendi for the first time.
Shoghi Effendi named Mr. Olinga the “Father of
Victories” for his services to the Faith and all
that he had accomplished as a pioneer and
travel-teacher in Africa.
When he returned to Africa, after his
pilgrimage, Shoghi Effendi appointed Enoch
Olinga a Hand of the Cause of God. He was the
youngest of all the Hands and he had been a
Bahá’í for only four years.
As a Hand of the Cause, Enoch Olinga carried
the news of the spread of the Faith to Bahá’ís all over the world. “Are you happy?” he always
asked. He wanted all the believers to be
happy. The believers should be happy, he said,
because they recognized Bahá’u’lláh and His
teachings.
Mr. Olinga traveled around the world. He would
tell all the Bahá’ís he met to carry Bahá’u’lláh’s
special message to others in their families,
their towns, and around the world. He was
reminding them of Bahá'u'lláh’s words: “The
first duty prescribed by God for His servants is
the recognition of Him Who is the Dayspring of
His Revelation... Whoso achieveth this duty
hath attained unto all good… It behoveth every
one … to observe every ordinance of Him Who
is the Desire of the world. These twin duties
are inseparable. Neither is acceptable without
the other…”
3
Enoch Olinga’s obedience to Bahá’u’lláh’s laws
and teachings changed him from a small and troubled soul to one who influenced thousands
of people around the world.
He transformed himself  from a drop into an
ocean. We can do that too…


source : http://www.spiritual-education.org/intro.html